1. 教城討論區」部分討論區之服務將於2021年2月1日正式停用,主要為討論主題已過時或使用率極低的討論區,包括「TVNews Student Forum」。若您需要備份內容,請於上述日期前自行儲存。如有任何查詢,歡迎致電 2624 1000或電郵至info@edcity.hk與我們聯絡。

    感謝您的使用及支持!

    Some forums under ‘HKEdCity Forums’ will be decommissioned on 1 February 2021. They are mostly forums with outdated discussion topics or extremely low usage, including ‘TVNews Student Forum’. If you need to back up your contents, please save them before this date. For any enquiries, please contact us on 2624 1000 or info@edcity.hk.

    Thank you for your support.

    排除通知

[Ex 1(J); Ex 1(S)] Protest at MTR station over musical instrument ban

本文由 J.L. 在 2015-10-05 發表於 "TVNews Student Forum" 討論區

  1. 56625141

    J.L.
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    253
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?

    Other relevant links:
    1. News Practice (Junior)
    2. News Practice (Senior)
    3. News Archive
    (Login is required, by HKEdCity student or teacher accounts.)
     
  2. 57512325

    onefatpiglol
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    19
    讚:
    0
    本帖最後由 onefatpiglol 於 2015-10-6 16:23 編輯

    [font=微軟雅黑]1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I personally can play guitar and piano,I think both of them are not allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes I think so because it's very inconvenient for the musician who need to go to perform.Maybe MTR should add a cart to let the passengers to keep their luggages.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes because I once saw a mainlander carry a cart with a lot of boxes on it.She hit many passengers but none of the staff stop her.I think this is very unfair.[/font]
     
    #2 onefatpiglol, 2015-10-06
  3. 57512324

    Hi i am MIllion
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    23
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play guitar. I think it is not allowed as it is big.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train. It is because MTR is an important transport for the Hong Kong people. If the MTR does not allow people to bring huge musical instruments, it is very inconvenient for the people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    I think the MTR staff is not executing the regulations with bias. It is because the length, width and height of some music instruments are similar to the baggage which is not allowed. Therefore I think the staff was just executing the regulations according to the rules.
     
    #3 Hi i am MIllion, 2015-10-06
  4. 57591386

    cwg-414425
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    14
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I do not play any musical instrument.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes, because musical instrument is not like other baggage if it is not allow to bring it is very inconvenient for the people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    i do not think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias because they are employed by MTR. I think that they just follow the rule to finish their job.
     
    #4 cwg-414425, 2015-10-06
  5. 57409177

    nickname-ls-651066
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I don't play any musical instrument.But I think MTR should allow people to bring their musical instrument.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes,it is because the musical instruments don't have danger and it is inconvenient for people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    No,it is because they just finish their jobs.
     
    #5 nickname-ls-651066, 2015-10-06
  6. 57297046

    cyc-748258
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    7
    讚:
    0
    1. I play flute and it's allowed.
    2. I think it should be given because it's inconvenient for the people to bring the musical instruments by others transportations if it's not allowed . For instance , if you bring it by bus, it will be easily to obstruct people to get in or off.
    3. I don't think so that the musical instruments really exceed the permitted length while the cans, the passages mentioned, may not exceed the permitted length.
     
    #6 cyc-748258, 2015-10-06
  7. 57296980

    dms
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    58
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?

    1. Yes, I play musical instruments ,it is guzheng. According to the current MTR regulations , guzheng is not allowed to bring on the MTR.


    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?

    2. I agree that the musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train as for most of the Hong Kong citizens , MTR train is the most convenient transport when you are carrying a musical instrument , it is cheap and you need not to wait a long time even if you miss a train. There are suggestions that they mat take bus or taxi . In terms of the size and price, taxi is too small for some musical instruments , moreover it is too expensive of taking taxi. Or the other hand , for bus ,I agree that it is big enough to put musical instruments but somehow it is more expensive than MTR and the bus driver will not let you to bring such large baggage. Thus MTR is the only transportation that is big enough and cheap enough for us to bring the musical instruments.


    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?

    Yes , I agree that the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias . In terms of the height ,maybe some of the musical instrument is taller . However the width of those cans of milk powder or other unauthorized goods . Besides the playing musical instruments is legal while being a parallel goods trader is illegal . The MTR staff let them to get on the train and not allow the one who bring musical instruments is not fair.
     
  8. 57557775

    nickname-hmt-993632
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    113
    讚:
    0
    Yes, I play piano, and I know that it will definitely not being allowed to bring on the MTR, but also I don't think that I need to carry the piano around.



    No, because if the people bring very big instrument to the MTR, it will make the passengers to become inconvenient as they are too big and it take so many area to place it. Therefore I don't think that the musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train.



    No, I think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with no bias, because the luggage or cart may not really exceed the permitted length or weight, but usually the big kind of musical instrument did.
     
    #8 nickname-hmt-993632, 2015-10-06
  9. 57591456

    nickname-cwg-322919
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    The Hong Kong MTR is to ruled for this things.
     
    #9 nickname-cwg-322919, 2015-10-06
  10. 57591478

    ;p
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    125
    讚:
    0
    1. No,I haven't.

    2.Yes,because it don not have any disadvantage on given flexibility of musical instruments on the MTR train

    3.yes.because other people bring something oversize but the staff does not stop them and help them put that thing into mtr
     
  11. 57409063

    nickname-ls-803010
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1.Yes,i have. I played handbell at school, but i don't think i need to carry it around.

    2.Yes. MTR is the most convenient transportation in Hong Kong i think. Play musical instruments which demonstrate the culturally diverse city. Hong Kong has become a laughing stock if the MTR bans the passengers to carry their musical instruments. In order to affect others on the train. I suggest the MTR should give flexibility to musical instruments.

    3.NO, i think the MTR staff is just executing the regulations what the MTR cooperation claims. Maybe some of the staffs hadn't strict execute the regulations before.
     
    #11 nickname-ls-803010, 2015-10-06
  12. 57924309

    nickname-twg-561896
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    Yes,I play the piano.No,it isn't allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.I even can't move the piano.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes,I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because the musical instruments don't obstruct others .Although some of instruments are too big and obstruct the others ,the staffs of MTR also should be flexibility the instruments since most of the people who carry musical instruments are the students who learning music and they need the instruments very much.The staffs just need to tell the people who carry the instruments stand beside of the MTR.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes,I think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias,as one passenger in the clip suggested because most of the staffs don't pay attention in their work and they always don't let the big musical instruments go into the MTR.However,I think this regulations want to avoid the people who transport smuggled goods and they are bad for the society .The staff don't execut the people who transport smuggled goods but the studnts carrying musical instruments and it's not fair.
     
    #12 nickname-twg-561896, 2015-10-06
  13. 57591476

    nickname-cwg-592034
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    - No, I don't play musical instruments. It is only allowed with the sum of the three sides do not exceed 170cm and each side does not exceeds 130cm. Also, the weight cannot exceeds 23kg.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    - Yes, I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train. It is because if they don't let people carry their musical instruments on the MTR train, this would be so inconvenient to them. Also, traveling on another transport might be more expensive and they may not afford the money.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    - Yes, I think so. It is because the staff let the people who is carrying the goods without tax to go in but not the people who is carrying the musical instruments, the attitude of the staff is bad and it is similar to discrimination, it is totally unfair to the people who carries the musical instruments.
     
    #13 nickname-cwg-592034, 2015-10-06
  14. 57782869

    nickname-lp1-328146
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    19
    讚:
    0
    1.No.
    2.No.Because the passegers have free to what they bring.
    3.No.Because it will the passergers less convient.
     
    #14 nickname-lp1-328146, 2015-10-06
  15. 57409120

    nickname-ls-814043
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1.No,I haven't.
    2.Yes,because many people in Hong Kong go to school or other places by MTR and it is very inconvenient for the people that have to carry the musical instrument to other places if they cannot carry it in the MTR station.
    3.Yes,because there are many people carry somthing that a bigger than the musical intrument but the straff does not stop them.
     
    #15 nickname-ls-814043, 2015-10-06
  16. 57710266

    nickname-cwg-717839
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    Yes,I am playing guiter.No,it's too big.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes.It's because musical instruments is not a baggage.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    No.The MTR staff must listened other passagers' opinion.
     
    #16 nickname-cwg-717839, 2015-10-06
  17. 57591420

    nickname-cwg-192848
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    回覆 1# J.L.


    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations? No

    2.Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why? Yes, it's because some kinds of musical instruments are big , if it's not allow to bring musical instruments, it will be very inconvenient to the people who play music.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why? No.it's because the staff doesn't want to get in trouble.
     
    #17 nickname-cwg-192848, 2015-10-06
  18. 57924326

    nickname-twg-521968
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    5
    讚:
    0
    I play musical instrument and I play the piano.It is not allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because people who carry the musical instruments usually need to have the lessons or a show.It is very inconvenice if we can't hake them into the MTR train.I think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested because the regulations is unreasonable and it can make us more convenience.
     
    #18 nickname-twg-521968, 2015-10-06
  19. 57357224

    nickname-wws-107493
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play viloin.is allowed

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    I think musical instruments should be given.cuz mtr is the most popular and environmental friendly transportation,musical instrument is one of the need for those people who are playing music,if mtr are not allowed them to take the instrument,I guess this cause a lot of inconvenience

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Not really,sometimes the luggage is not that prominent to estimate the size is over or not,but some of the musical instruments is clearly over the size,so mtr staff need to do something for stopping ppl carry big size of things
     
    #19 nickname-wws-107493, 2015-10-07
  20. Expand Collapse

    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I do not play any musical instrument
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes , I think so . It is because MTR is the most popular transport nowadays in Hong Kong . Sometimes you may need to bring your musical instrument to somewhere only can go by MTR to have a show . Moreover , MTR is faster than any other transport/
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    No, I do not think so . Since I never see someone who bring a big package in the train.