1. 教城討論區」部分討論區之服務將於2021年2月1日正式停用,主要為討論主題已過時或使用率極低的討論區,包括「TVNews Student Forum」。若您需要備份內容,請於上述日期前自行儲存。如有任何查詢,歡迎致電 2624 1000或電郵至info@edcity.hk與我們聯絡。

    感謝您的使用及支持!

    Some forums under ‘HKEdCity Forums’ will be decommissioned on 1 February 2021. They are mostly forums with outdated discussion topics or extremely low usage, including ‘TVNews Student Forum’. If you need to back up your contents, please save them before this date. For any enquiries, please contact us on 2624 1000 or info@edcity.hk.

    Thank you for your support.

    排除通知

[Ex 1(J); Ex 1(S)] Protest at MTR station over musical instrument ban

本文由 J.L. 在 2015-10-05 發表於 "TVNews Student Forum" 討論區

  1. 57594665

    nickname-kc-837787
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    answer:yes,i play violin.yes,its allowed in the mtr regulation.
     
    #121 nickname-kc-837787, 2015-10-22
  2. 57337854

    nickname-gps-408324
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    回覆 1# J.L.
    1. I don't play any musical instruments.
    2. I think the musical instruments should not be given flexibility because it will affect others safety.
    3. I think the MTR staff is not executing the regulations with bias because they just follow the rules to work.
     
    #122 nickname-gps-408324, 2015-10-25
  3. 57337773

    Jade Wong Wing Yu
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?

    Answer: I play Gu Zhang and it is not allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Answer: No, it is because massive musical instruments may block the MTR train and cause disturbance to passengers.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Answer: Yes, it is because the regulations are observed not to be fair.
     
    #123 Jade Wong Wing Yu, 2015-10-25
  4. 57594664

    nickname-kc-563314
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    1.I play the small size guitar.It is allowed on the MTR.
    2.Yes,because it may be disencouragement for musicians if the regulations are so strict.
    3Yes,because one time someone bring an oversized object but the MTR staff still allow it.
     
    #124 nickname-kc-563314, 2015-10-25
  5. 57337801

    gps-112215=)
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    17
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play percussion , and of course it is not allowed since they are too big.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes. Because people might need them now and the faster transport is the mtr. I suggest they make a small counter to put down big instruments and get them back after the ride.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes , because when I get onto the mtr , I always see travelers like mainlander holding luggage and it hit a lot of people some people complained but nothing happened.
     
    #125 gps-112215=), 2015-10-25
  6. 57979134

    nickname-stg-694178
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    4
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I do not play any musical instrument.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes, because musical instrument is not like other baggage if it is not allow to bring it is very inconvenient for the people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    i do not think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias because they are employed by MTR. I think that they just follow the rule to finish their job.
     
    #126 nickname-stg-694178, 2015-10-25
  7. 57584708

    nickname-css-293421
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    6
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play the piano.It is not allow to carry on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes.Since all people have different needs and it is their rights to carry their properties on the MTR trian.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes.The MTR staff allows people to carry many cans of milk powder on to the train but not allows people to carry musical instument.
     
    #127 nickname-css-293421, 2015-10-30
  8. 57580555

    ____K
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I haven't play for a long time.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility because musical instruments won't hurt anyone.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes because they against the people that bring musical instruments, and not grey goods traders.
     
  9. 57337936

    nickname-gps-218672
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    4
    讚:
    0
    本帖最後由 nickname-gps-218672 於 2015-10-31 20:52 編輯

    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so , what kind of musical instrument do you play? is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    Yes, I play piano and recorder. Piano can not be moved easily and recorder is very handy.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes. It is because there are many students learning to play musical instruments and it would be hard for them if they cannot travel with their musical instruments on the major transportation MTR.


    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the relations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    No. It is because i dont think MTR have enough staff to check every gate.
     
    #129 nickname-gps-218672, 2015-10-31
  10. 57910651

    nickname-kwk-349979
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    24
    讚:
    0
    1. ?Yes,I play the flute.it is allowed on the MTR accord to current MTR regulations.

    2. Yes,because some instuments sre quite small.

    3. No, because they just do not want people feel crowded in the MTR train.
     
    #130 nickname-kwk-349979, 2015-11-01
  11. 57931839

    nickname-kc-377290
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    1. No, I haven't.

    2. Yes, because the student may be need to attend some instrument classes but they can just travel by bus.

    3. Yes, because I have seen that some people had carried something that is oversize then the regulation.
     
    #131 nickname-kc-377290, 2015-11-01
  12. 57810293

    nickname-kc-811367
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    I play the harmonica

    2.Yes as it is the rights of human under not affecting other interest of other passaenger.
    3. I think the MTR staff is not executing the regulations with bias because there would be different kind of regulations made by MTR staff ,making it unfair for some of passengers.
     
    #132 nickname-kc-811367, 2015-11-01
  13. 57567051

    audrey ho 134217
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    I play violin. I have no problem carrying it in the MTRS.
     
    #133 audrey ho 134217, 2015-11-01
  14. 57567051

    audrey ho 134217
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    2. Flexibility should be given to all kinds of musical instruments, expect those very large in size, such as harp and piano. After all nobody will carry a piano into the MTR.
    The flexibility is a kind of support students who are leaning musical instruments.
     
    #134 audrey ho 134217, 2015-11-01
  15. 57337477

    nickname-gps-253502
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    51
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play the flute. And the MTR is allowed to carry it inside the train.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes, because music can bring happiness to people, so they shouldn't limited the size of musical instruments.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    I do not think so, as they are the employee by the MTR corporation.

    請讚好。
     
    #135 nickname-gps-253502, 2015-11-01
  16. 57579678

    Dean Winchester
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    37
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?

    Ans: I don't play any musical instruments.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?

    Ans: Yes. It's because it will be more convenient for the people to take their instruments around HK

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?

    Ans: Yes. It's because the MTR staff didn't execute these regulations on the mainland Chinese passengers.
     
    #136 Dean Winchester, 2015-11-03
  17. 57905403

    nickname-lsp-450983
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    1.No, I don't play any musical instrument.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    2.Yes, because most student MTR.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes, because they mostly executing student with huge musical instruments.
     
    #137 nickname-lsp-450983, 2015-11-04
  18. 57924325

    nickname-twg-914476
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    1.I play piano.It is not allowed.

    2.Yes,I do.Because they are also not allowed in other transports.

    3.No,I don't.Because the staff maybe do not see the other passengers who carry the over size things.
     
    #138 nickname-twg-914476, 2015-11-05
  19. 57924325

    nickname-twg-914476
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    1.I play piano.It is not allowed.

    2.Yes,I do.Because they are also not allowed in other transports.

    3.No,I don't.Because the staff maybe do not see the other passengers who carry the over size things.
     
    #139 nickname-twg-914476, 2015-11-05
  20. 57465980

    nickname-w5c-306569
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    61
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I didn't play any music instruments.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes since we have rights to bring our personal belongings to MTR trains.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes, I think this is the problem bring by specific staffs.
     
    #140 nickname-w5c-306569, 2015-11-08