1. 教城討論區」部分討論區之服務將於2021年2月1日正式停用,主要為討論主題已過時或使用率極低的討論區,包括「TVNews Student Forum」。若您需要備份內容,請於上述日期前自行儲存。如有任何查詢,歡迎致電 2624 1000或電郵至info@edcity.hk與我們聯絡。

    感謝您的使用及支持!

    Some forums under ‘HKEdCity Forums’ will be decommissioned on 1 February 2021. They are mostly forums with outdated discussion topics or extremely low usage, including ‘TVNews Student Forum’. If you need to back up your contents, please save them before this date. For any enquiries, please contact us on 2624 1000 or info@edcity.hk.

    Thank you for your support.

    排除通知

[Ex 1(J); Ex 1(S)] Protest at MTR station over musical instrument ban

本文由 J.L. 在 2015-10-05 發表於 "TVNews Student Forum" 討論區

  1. 57763223

    nickname-w5c-553371
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    60
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    Ans: Yes, I do play musical instrument. I play the violin. It is allowed to on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Ans: yes, I think so. It is because MTR is the most convenient way for the people that need to carry the musical instruments, especially is the big instruments.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Ans: No, I don't think so. It is because the length, width and height of some music instruments are similar to the baggage which is not allowed.However, some people's brought some much bigger language such as the washing machines still can allow to go in.
     
    #141 nickname-w5c-553371, 2015-11-09
  2. 57655848

    nickname-fk1-556572
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    41
    讚:
    0
    . I play flute and it's allowed.
    2. I think it should be given because it's inconvenient for the people to bring the musical instruments by others transportations if it's not allowed . For instance , if you bring it by bus, it will be easily to obstruct people to get in or off.
    3. I don't think so that the musical instruments really exceed the permitted length while the cans, the passages mentioned, may not exceed the permitted length.
     
    #142 nickname-fk1-556572, 2015-11-10
  3. 57773478

    nickname-stg-847923
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    6
    讚:
    0
    1.No,I do not play any musical instruments
    2.No,because some of musical instruments is too big and bring to the MTR,it will make passengers become inconvenient and do not have much area to place
    3.No, I think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with no bias,because they just finish their jobs.
     
    #143 nickname-stg-847923, 2015-11-14
  4. 57881196

    nickname-lp1-203236
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    26
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play guitar. I think it is not allowed as it is big.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train. It is because MTR is an important transport for the Hong Kong people. If the MTR does not allow people to bring huge musical instruments, it is very inconvenient for the people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    I think the MTR staff is not executing the regulations with bias. It is because the length, width and height of some music instruments are similar to the baggage which is not allowed. Therefore I think the staff was just executing the regulations according to the rules.
     
    #144 nickname-lp1-203236, 2015-11-15
  5. 57881196

    nickname-lp1-203236
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    26
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play guitar. I think it is not allowed as it is big.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train. It is because MTR is an important transport for the Hong Kong people. If the MTR does not allow people to bring huge musical instruments, it is very inconvenient for the people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    I think the MTR staff is not executing the regulations with bias. It is because the length, width and height of some music instruments are similar to the baggage which is not allowed. Therefore I think the staff was just executing the regulations according to the rules.
     
    #145 nickname-lp1-203236, 2015-11-15
  6. 57402089

    nickname-stg-241199
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    A: I am a guitarist, if the MTR do not allow me to bring my instrument, it makes me very inconvenient.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    A: I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train if don't the musician will feel very inconvenient when they are carrying some
    big instruments.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    A: Yes. A lot of mainland people always carrying some big packages, some of them are bigger than the instruments , but the staff do not stop the mainland people, so i think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias.
     
    #146 nickname-stg-241199, 2015-11-15
  7. 57881196

    nickname-lp1-203236
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    26
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play guitar. I think it is not allowed as it is big.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train. It is because MTR is an important transport for the Hong Kong people. If the MTR does not allow people to bring huge musical instruments, it is very inconvenient for the people.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    I think the MTR staff is not executing the regulations with bias. It is because the length, width and height of some music instruments are similar to the baggage which is not allowed. Therefore I think the staff was just executing the regulations according to the rules.
     
    #147 nickname-lp1-203236, 2015-11-16
  8. 57700917

    nickname-sps-896321
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    22
    讚:
    0
    Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    Yes,I play the clarinet and the piano.I think clarinet is allowed om train but piano is not allowed since it is too large.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes,it is much convenience for people to bring their instrument back home.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes , I agree that the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias .Playing musical instruments is legal while being a parallel goods trader is illegal . The MTR staff let them to get on the train but not allow the one who bring musical instruments,it is not fair.
     
    #148 nickname-sps-896321, 2015-11-20
  9. 57924435

    nickname-twg-464075
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    No,I do not play any musical instrument. If so, I would like to play the violin because it is small and also not exceed the weight . It is allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations . :D :) :kissingsmiling: :blush: :relaxed: {:3_48:}
     
    #149 nickname-twg-464075, 2015-11-23
  10. 57782952

    lp1-s20141008
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    1.NO

    2.YES because it makes people relax.

    3.no
     
    #150 lp1-s20141008, 2015-11-29
  11. 57924446

    nickname-twg-966611
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    10
    讚:
    0
    The MTR is unreasonable to has a rule of the any music instruments. The music instruments is important to some people who need to use music instruments for work.
     
    #151 nickname-twg-966611, 2015-12-01
  12. 57791516

    nickname-lsp-908006
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    8
    讚:
    0
    1.No, I haven't
    2.No, because they are seriously take musical instrument in MTR station , they are violate the regulation.
    3. Yes, because they like playing music that they may take them yo work.
     
    #152 nickname-lsp-908006, 2015-12-03
  13. 57337482

    nickname-gps-868917
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    12
    讚:
    0
    I played............









    piano and it is not allowed....:cry:
     
    #153 nickname-gps-868917, 2015-12-06
  14. 57931759

    nickname-kc-635966
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    I play piano. I cannot take my piano to the street, or even taking MTR.
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because buses and minibuses are not allowed for passengers to carry big musical instruments when they are onboard.
     
    #154 nickname-kc-635966, 2015-12-27
  15. 57710176

    nickname-cwg-632166
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    15
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I don't play any musical instrument.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    no, because some of the musical instruments is very large,when there are many passengers in the train,it may affect other passengers or hurt them carelessly.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    No,it is because the MTR staff are responsible to do their job according the rules of MTR company.
     
    #155 nickname-cwg-632166, 2015-12-29
  16. 57710176

    nickname-cwg-632166
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    15
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I do not play any musical instrument.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    no, because some of the musical instrument are large,they may effect or hurt other passengers if there are many passengers in the train carelessly.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    i do not think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias because they are the workers of MTR company,so they have responsibility to do their job according the rules of MTR company.
     
    #156 nickname-cwg-632166, 2015-12-29
  17. 57567045

    nickname-gps-742164
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    I play a Trombone , it is not allow for the MTR.
    yes , I think so because the people can take the instrument by themself.
    no,I think not.
     
    #157 nickname-gps-742164, 2016-01-17
  18. 57567045

    nickname-gps-742164
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    I play a Trombone , it is not allow for the MTR.
    yes , I think so because the people can take the instrument by themself.
    no,I think not.
     
    #158 nickname-gps-742164, 2016-01-17
  19. 57117939

    nickname-kwk-889334
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    5
    讚:
    1
    DOnt be so noob
     
    #159 nickname-kwk-889334, 2016-01-19
  20. 57791522

    nickname-lsp-119504
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    47
    讚:
    0
    I don't play any musical instrument. I agree that the musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR.
     
    #160 nickname-lsp-119504, 2016-02-03