1. 教城討論區」部分討論區之服務將於2021年2月1日正式停用,主要為討論主題已過時或使用率極低的討論區,包括「TVNews Student Forum」。若您需要備份內容,請於上述日期前自行儲存。如有任何查詢,歡迎致電 2624 1000或電郵至info@edcity.hk與我們聯絡。

    感謝您的使用及支持!

    Some forums under ‘HKEdCity Forums’ will be decommissioned on 1 February 2021. They are mostly forums with outdated discussion topics or extremely low usage, including ‘TVNews Student Forum’. If you need to back up your contents, please save them before this date. For any enquiries, please contact us on 2624 1000 or info@edcity.hk.

    Thank you for your support.

    排除通知

[Ex 1(J); Ex 1(S)] Protest at MTR station over musical instrument ban

本文由 J.L. 在 2015-10-05 發表於 "TVNews Student Forum" 討論區

  1. 57791522

    nickname-lsp-119504
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    47
    讚:
    0
    I don't play any musical instrument. I agree that the musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR.
     
    #161 nickname-lsp-119504, 2016-02-04
  2. 57700872

    nickname-sps-191601
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    27
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    No, I haven't.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes, it is unfair to the people who play large instrument.It is very inconvenient for them.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    I do not think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias because they are employed by MTR. I think that they just follow the rule to finish their job.
     
    #162 nickname-sps-191601, 2016-02-05
  3. 57949719

    nickname-sps-542584
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    2
    讚:
    0
    1. Yes,I paly cello.It is not allow to bring it into the MTR during busy hours.
    2. Yes,because MTR is a kind of convenient transportation.
    3. Yes,many peoples bring oversize luggages to the MTR but those on duty staff didn't stop them.
     
    #163 nickname-sps-542584, 2016-02-09
  4. 57949712

    Kaylie Lam
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    Question 1:
    I play the piano in my free time. It is the heavy so it is not allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
    Question 2:
    I think musical instruments should not be given flexibility on the MTR train. It is because some musical instruments are very big and heavy. Such as, piano, double base.
    Question 3:
    I think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested. It is because the passengers can suggested everything freely.
     
    #164 Kaylie Lam, 2016-02-11
  5. 57949671

    nickname-sps-314621
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    16
    讚:
    0
    I play the recorder and it is allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
     
    #165 nickname-sps-314621, 2016-02-15
  6. 57949671

    nickname-sps-314621
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    16
    讚:
    0
    I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because HK most convenience transportation is MTR ,and these musical instruments is like a school bag of these students ,it is only a bit larger.
     
    #166 nickname-sps-314621, 2016-02-15
  7. 57949671

    nickname-sps-314621
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    16
    讚:
    0
    I do not think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias because they are employee of the MTR. I think that they are just following their boss to finish their job.
     
    #167 nickname-sps-314621, 2016-02-15
  8. 57949681

    nickname-sps-270807
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    13
    讚:
    0
    1. Yes, i play guitar, i'm not sure if it is allowed.
    2.Yes, i think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because many people plays musical instruments.
    3. Yes, i think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested, because i think that passenger did not did anything wrong.
     
    #168 nickname-sps-270807, 2016-02-15
  9. 57337561

    nickname-gps-359166
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    7
    讚:
    0
    1. I play musical instrument, it is a Cello. It didn't allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
    2. I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because if some students live a very faraway from the school, he or she
    only can use the MTR, but the stuff didn't let they take the musical instrument, so how the student study?
    3. No because the stuff don't let all of them in.
    :mad::mad: :
     
    #169 nickname-gps-359166, 2016-02-27
  10. 57949731

    Nicole Yu
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    3
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play violin and piano. I know violin is on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.

    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes, I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train. Because when the musicans need to bring their instruments for performances or trainings, it is inconvenient for them.

    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias , as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes I think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, Beause sometimes i saw some of the MTR staff allow the people who bring big luggages.
     
    #170 Nicole Yu, 2016-04-04
  11. 57949717

    nickname-sps-405346
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    22
    讚:
    0
    1. I do not play any musical instrument.
    2.Yes, I think it should be because many people use MTR and many people play musical instrument too, it may cause inconvenience of the intrument player.
    3.No, I think it is no need to do that because it is not commom to see people bringing a big luggage.
     
    #171 nickname-sps-405346, 2016-05-22
  12. 57700872

    nickname-sps-191601
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    27
    讚:
    0
    1. Do you play any musical instrument and, if so, what kind of musical instrument do you play? Is it allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations?
    I play piano and it is not allowed on the MTR according to the current MTR regulations.
    2. Do you think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train? Why?
    Yes, I think musical instruments should be given flexibility on the MTR train because MTR is a public transport.It is a convenient transport for us to travel around. If it is not allowed to carry on the MTR, people with the big musical instruments will find it difficult to go to their destination.
    3. Do you think the MTR staff is executing the regulations with bias, as one passenger in the clip suggested? Why?
    Yes, I do. Sometimes I see some mainlanders bring with them a lot of milk powder with them. However, the staff do not stop them and allow them to do so. It is unfair for the people with huge instruments.
     
    #172 nickname-sps-191601, 2016-07-24