[Summer 4.4(S)] Discuss: Legislator disqualifications

本文由 J.L. 在 2017-07-19 發表於 "TVNews Student Forum" 討論區

  1. 56625141

    J.L.
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    253
    讚:
    0
    1. What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    2. Who do you agree / disagree with most in the clip? Why?
     
  2. 57700997

    nickname-sps-341312
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    37
    讚:
    0
    1.What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    I think it is right to disqualify the legislator as they didn't know how to respect the system of Legislative Council. They didn't pledge normally as others, instead , they screamed out some disrespectful slogans or brought a yellow umbrella during pledge . So I think it is right to disqualify the four legislators regarded their disrespectful and irresponsible actions.

    2.Who do you agree / disagree with most in the clip? Why?
    I don't agree that the legislative council will become a "rubber stamp" after the legislator disqualifications/ I think after six legislators' disqualification , there are still a lot of professional legislators in the Legislative council that they can still makes careful and thoughtful decisions for citizens therefore I think the Legislative council won't become a " rubber stamp" that makes careless decisions.
     
    #2 nickname-sps-341312, 2017-07-20
  3. 57700873

    nickname-sps-967249
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    119
    讚:
    0
    1. I think it is a right decision to disqualify the four legislators because they do not know how to respect the Legislative Council. They do not respect themselves when they are swearing. If they do not respect the Legislative Council, they do not have the qualifications to play a role in the Legislative Council. Therefore, it is the right decision to disqualify the four legislators.

    2. I don't agree that the legislative council will become a "rubber stamp" after the legislator disqualifications/ I think after six legislators' disqualification , there are still a lot of professional legislators in the Legislative council that they can still makes careful and thoughtful decisions for citizens therefore I think the Legislative council won't become a " rubber stamp" that makes careless decisions.
     
    #3 nickname-sps-967249, 2017-07-21
  4. 57949662

    nickname-sps-864999
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    30
    讚:
    0
    -What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    It is unfair for them.

    Who do you agree / disagree with most in the clip? Why
    I think they should not be treated like that
     
    #4 nickname-sps-864999, 2017-07-21
  5. 57568803

    nickname-olc-589197
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    1
    讚:
    0
    What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    It is unfair for them.They have the right to be the legislator
    2.I don't agree the legislative council.
     
    #5 nickname-olc-589197, 2017-07-22
  6. 57513295

    nickname-kan-360170
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    10
    讚:
    0
    1.it is unfair
    2.I do not agree the legislative council because I think that the establishment lawmakers of Hong Kong should have their idea and thinking about something.
     
    #6 nickname-kan-360170, 2017-07-22
  7. 57700924

    nickname-sps-701441
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    45
    讚:
    0
    1. I agree to my full extend to the legislator disqualifications. The four people do not know how to respect solemn occasion in the Legislative Council. They have been trying to attempt to polarize Hong Kong and challenging the legality of Basic Law.
    2. I agree most with Priscilla Leung's remark.
     
    #7 nickname-sps-701441, 2017-07-24
  8. 57701024

    nickname-sps-690710
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    38
    讚:
    0
    1. I agree, because they don't respect the Legislative Council and their country.
    2. I agree the pro-establishment lawmakers because they welcomed the court ruling to the person don't respect Legislative Council.
     
    #8 nickname-sps-690710, 2017-07-24
  9. 57949699

    nickname-sps-286635
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    20
    讚:
    0
    1. I agree. The disqualified pan democrats have disrespected LegCo's oath taking system. The way they have behaved while taking the oath was also disrespectful towards the country. In some way, they have also disappointed the people who voted for them because they probably feel like they have been betrayed by the pan democrats after voting for them.
    2. I don't really agree with the usage of 'rubber stamp' by one of the legco members to describe the present situation in the legco. Apart from the disqualified pan democrats, there is still a great amount of people in the legco so they can continue the law making and vote taking with major problems.
     
    #9 nickname-sps-286635, 2017-07-25
  10. 57949644

    nickname-sps-273502
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    27
    讚:
    0
     
    #10 nickname-sps-273502, 2017-07-25
  11. 57380256

    PrairieYeung
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    6
    讚:
    0
    1. I think that it is half fair and unfair. I also think the people who disqualified them have their reasons.
    2. I don't know
     
    #11 PrairieYeung, 2017-07-26
  12. 57949645

    nickname-sps-281560
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    26
    讚:
    0
    1.I think it is right to disqualify the legislator who break the law and do not obey the law.It is the example of 'rule of law' in Hong Kong.This show Hong Kong people's confident of having a fair decision.
    2.I agree with most of the clip as the one who violating or breaking the law should be punished or treated fairly by the law.Although they are disqualified ,they could still voice out the opinions of Hong Kong citizens by others ways.
     
    #12 nickname-sps-281560, 2017-07-26
  13. 57700917

    nickname-sps-896321
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    22
    讚:
    0
    1. What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    [FONT=LatoWeb, Helvetica Neue, Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif]I think it is right to do so, as they didn't respect the system of the legislation, they didn't abide the rule and pledge normally, therefore I think they should be punished,as an example to show and deterrent other legislator to do so. [/FONT]
    1. Who do you agree / disagree with most in the clip? Why?
    I don't agree that the legislative council will become a "rubber stamp" after the legislator disqualifications. Instead I think the legislative council can work more effectively and smoothly, because there are fewer legislator can veto and filibuster .
     
    #13 nickname-sps-896321, 2017-07-27
  14. 57949697

    nickname-sps-931647
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    11
    讚:
    0
    I think it is a right decision because people who do not follow the rules should be punished. Also they are not respectful to both their jobs and the country.
    i do not agree with the leg c because they should have the rights to express their reasons behind too.
     
    #14 nickname-sps-931647, 2017-07-27
  15. 57700901

    nickname-sps-318609
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    15
    讚:
    0
    1. I think it is right decision because they do not respect the oath and not follow the rules. And it is a serious moment and place that should be respected. So they should have some punishment in order to show the solemness of the swearing ceremonies.

    2. I agree with Andrew Leung that the Legislative Council will not become a "rubber stamp" after the legislator disqualification because if less legislators cause disorder, the conference will run more smoothly and they can discuss more things.
     
    #15 nickname-sps-318609, 2017-07-28
  16. 57949655

    nickname-sps-833405
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    29
    讚:
    0
    1. It's obvious that they are disqualified. If you can't even respect the oath/ Legislative Council, you should not have a seat in the Legislative Council. It's not even about breaking the law, let's put that aside, it's about respecting HK and the country. Respect is one of the most basic things we do.
    2. Leung Kwok-Hung said he got nothing to regret. Of course he's got stuff to regret, regret about not respecting the country, regret about disappointing HIS supporters, because he can't even get into the Legislative Council. There are still people who believed in Leung, thinking that he can do something for HK. But he can't even get into it. I personally don't support him, but I think he at least has to be responsible for the sake of his supporters.
     
    #16 nickname-sps-833405, 2017-07-29
  17. 57949788

    nickname-sps-679305
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    16
    讚:
    0
    1 It's unfair
    2 I agree
     
    #17 nickname-sps-679305, 2017-07-30
  18. 57700964

    nickname-sps-623644
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    19
    讚:
    0
    1. I agree to my full extend to the legislator disqualifications. The four people do not know how to respect solemn occasion in the Legislative Council. They have been trying to attempt to polarize Hong Kong and challenging the legality of Basic Law.
    I agree to the pro-establishment lawmakers because they welcomed the court ruling to the person doesn't respect Legislative Council.
     
    #18 nickname-sps-623644, 2017-07-31
  19. 57949638

    nickname-sps-617905
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    35
    讚:
    0
    1. What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    2. Who do you agree / disagree with most in the clip? Why?
    1. I think thet deserve disqualification as they did not respect the Legislative Council.
    2. I agree with Andrew Leung
     
    #19 nickname-sps-617905, 2017-08-01
  20. 57375148

    nickname-wy1-155739
    Expand Collapse

    文章:
    4
    讚:
    0
    1. What do you think about the legislator disqualifications?
    2. Who do you agree / disagree with most in the clip? Why?
    1. I agree with the court ruling.
    2.I agree with Priscilla Leung
     
    #20 nickname-wy1-155739, 2017-08-01